Dark Balsamic Vinegars
The Olive Tap Crystal Lake offers a full menu of aged, Dark Balsamic Vinegars, sure to please just about everyone’s palate. Our convenient sweetness scale, detailed vinegar tasting profiles and select recipes will guide you through our menu with ease.
To Order, simply fill-out our Contact Us Form and our Tasting Specialists will start processing your order right away.
Aceto Balsamico di Modena, 4 Leaf Quality
Formerly called Traditional 18 year style Balsamic Vinegar. PGI Certified. This is our finest and most popular on-tap Balsamic Vinegar of Modena.
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Aceto Balsamico di Modena, Riserva
Produced using a secret recipe handed down from father to son over 3 centuries, this is a very rich and thick traditional style Balsamic Vinegar of Modena, Similar to the 25 Star/25 year style Balsamic Vinegars, its high concentration of cooked grape must and long barrel aging result in a superior product reserved for lovers of Italian culinary tradition.
$24.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$47.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Blackberry Ginger Balsamic Vinegar
This Olive Tap Balsamic Vinegar features the luscious sweet-tart flavor of ripe Blackberries, accented by the tangy but gentle spiciness of fresh ginger.
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Bordeaux Cherry Riserva Balsamic Vinegar
Beautiful, dark, ripe, bordeaux cherry flavor enlivens this incredible Italian aged balsamic vinegar, giving a modern twist to this time honored classic. The rich cherry flavor will excel at flavoring meats, cheeses and salads. Fantastic as a sauce or glaze!
$22.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$43.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Bourbon Maple Balsamic Vinegar
Maple lovers and foodies rejoice! This expertly crafted explosion of flavor bomb is unrivaled in taste and quality. It is a multi-dimensional balsamic that delivers rich and complex flavor notes of maple, honey, charred oak, and spices.
$21.95 for 375 ml. (12.6 fl oz.)
$41.95 for 750 ml (25.3 fl oz)
Caramel Riserva Balsamic Vinegar
Smooth, creamy and delicious this is a flavorful Balsamic Vinegar that incorporates natural Caramel flavors with our Aceto Balsamico di Modena Riserva Balsamic Vinegar. No need to wait for dessert!
$22.95 for 375 ml. (12.6 fl oz.)
$43.95 for 750 ml (25.3 fl oz)
Cinnamon Pear Balsamic Vinegar – Limited Supply
Rich toasted cinnamon and the sweet taste of Pear are combined to make this savory and sweet Balsamic Vinegar. It makes a great marinade or glaze for pork or poultry. Pair it with Blood Orange Olive Oil for a delicious vinaigrette for a spinach salad with mandarin oranges and goat cheese.
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Cranberry Walnut Riserva Balsamic Vinegar – Limited Supply
This popular Olive Tap seasonal offering that is a tried and true crowd pleaser whenever it is served. Made with a blend of dark Riserva Balsamic Vinegar and a special blend of seasonal flavors including cranberries and walnuts. It is a truly unique Balsamic Vinegar that can be used alone or paired with many of The Olive Tap’s Extra Virgin Olive Oils.
$22.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$43.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Dark Chocolate Balsamic Vinegar
This is a velvety-sweet, and very flavorful Balsamic Vinegar of Modena. It is truly a Chocolate lovers dream come true! No need to wait for dessert!
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Fig Riserva Balsamic Vinegar
Whole fruit flavor is added to a blend of 3 and 4 Leaf Quality Aceto Balsamico di Modena to produce our most balanced Balsamic Vinegar. Not too sweet and not too tart.
$22.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$43.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Hickory Barbeque Riserva Balsamic Vinegar
Rich, sweet and smoky, The Olive Tap Hickory Barbeque Riserva Balsamic Vinegar can easily become your secret ingredient on the grill or in the kitchen.
$22.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$43.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Habanero Honey Balsamic Vinegar
If you are looking for more complexity to your salads, marinades or grilled foods, try The Olive Tap’s Habanero Honey Balsamic Vinegar. Our gourmet vinegar exhibits both sweet and sour notes from the honey vinegar base but also a truly assertive kick from Habanero Peppers. Certainly on the top of our list for an incredibily balanced balsamic vinegar.
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Italian Herbs Riserva Balsamic Vinegar
NEW! Popular herbs including Oregano and Marjoram flavor a sweet, dense “Riserva” Balsamic Vinegar that may change how you approach salad dressing.
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Pomegranate Balsamic Vinegar
Native to Mediterranean, Asian and Middle Eastern cultures, this fruit exhibits a sweet-tart flavor that is a perfect accompaniment to a wide range of foods. Its unique, deep rich flavors and acidity to create a complex yet superbly balanced dressing and condiment. There are numerous reports on the health benefits of Pomegranate. Now get a health food that tastes great!
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Raspberry Balsamic Vinegar
This very popular Balsamic Vinegar is a tried and true crowd pleaser whenever it is served! It is one of the most adaptable Balsamic Vinegars, and can be used with any of the Olive Tap Extra Virgin Olive Oils to make flavorful Vinaigrettes.
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Red Apple Balsamic Vinegar – Limited Supply
This dark balsamic has an enticing aroma and a delicate, sweet apple flavor, fruitier than most balsamic vinegars, which combine to create a scrumptious and tasty vinegar that will produce delicious salads and glazes.
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Tangerine Balsamic Vinegar
Absolutely a customer favorite since the first Olive Tap opened in 2006. It pairs so well with such a wide variety of flavored and 100% extra virgin olive oils. The perfect blend of 3 and 4 Leaf Quality Balsamic Vinegar of Modena results in a low acid level, complimented by an intense and sweet citrus flavor that makes visitors to The Olive Tap say, “WOW”!
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Triple Berry Balsamic Vinegar
This Olive Tap proprietary Balsamic Vinegar is simply all about berries! An exquisite blend of our popular “Berry” Balsamic Vinegars from Modena, Italy; it truly seems like you are eating a mouthful of berries with just one taste! Perfectly balanced, this dark balsamic vinegar is not too tart, nor overly sweet, making it superb on salads and over fruits.
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz
Wild Blueberry Balsamic Vinegar
Blueberry lovers really “wildly” appreciate this addition to the Olive Tap’s line of Balsamic Vinegars of Modena. Our first impression was that this would be a huge hit drizzled over fruit salads, and garden salads topped with fresh fruits. We weren’t disappointed. As an added surprise, we found it equally delicious over Blue, Feta and Goat Cheeses.
$21.95 for 375 ml / 12.6 fl oz
$41.95 for 750 ml / 25.3 fl oz